Commenting Policy

Academe welcomes thoughtful comments on the articles we publish. Comments must be approved by a moderator before they appear. We are committed to maintaining a respectful tone even on hotly contested issues; while criticism of ideas is welcome, ad hominem attacks are not.  Promotional comments are not allowed. Some tips on commenting etiquette are below. We reserve the right to close commenting on an article or reject comments we deem inappropriate.

We encourage commenters to use their real names, though pseudonymous comments are also permitted as long as you do not impersonate someone else.

By posting a comment, you have agreed to comply with our privacy policy and terms of use

If you have a question or a concern about our policies, we'd be happy to hear from you. Please contact

Commenting Etiquette:

  • Don't post in all caps.
  • Don't attack other commenters.
  • Don't post comments that serve mainly to promote your book, blog, or cause.